
|
Abstracts of Research Articles Available Online
and in Print |
Perspective
as a Symmetry Transformation György
Darvas (Spring 2003) From the quattrocento
to the end of the nineteenth century, perspective has been the
main tool of artists aiming to paint a naturalistic representation
of our environment. In painters' perspective we find a combination
of affine projection and similitude. We recognise the original
object in the painting because perspective is a symmetry transformation
preserving certain features. The subject of the transformation,
in the case of perspectival representation, is visible reality,
and the transformed object is the artwork. The application of
symmetry transformations developed from the origin of perspective
through the centuries to the present day. The single vanishing
point could be moved (translated), and even doubled, developments
that made it possible to represent an object from different points
of view. In the twentieth cenutyr, the application of topological
symmetry combined with similitude resulted in new ways of seeing,
new tools for artists such as cubists and futurists.
Distance
to the Perspective Plane Tomás García-Salgado
(Spring 2003) Distance
is an integral concept in perspective, both ancient and modern.
Tomás García-Salgado provides a historical survey
of the concept of distance, then goes on to draw some geometric
conclusions that relate distance to theories of vision, representation,
and techniques of observation in the field. This paper clarifies
the principles behind methods of dealing with the perspective
of space, in contrast to those dealing with the perspective of
objects, and examines the perspective method of Pomponius Gauricus,
contrasting it with the method of Alberti. Finally the symmetry
of the perspective plane is discussed.
From
the Vaults of Heaven Marco Jaff (Spring 2003) Many clues lead Marco
Jaff to conjecture that Brunelleschi knew about the use of the
astrolabe, an instrument very often used in his times; among
his friendships we find the astronomer Paolo Dal Pozzo and engineer
Mariano di Jacopo da Siena, who certainly knew how to use the
astrolabe accurately. Because this instrument is based on the
principle of stereographic projection, a particular kind of central
projection, it is quite possible that Filippo applied this principle
either for the perspective construction outline for Masaccio's
Trinità in S. Maria Novella, as well as for the two lost
panels of the Baptistery of Florence.
Speculations
on the Origins of Linear Perspective Richard Talbot
(Spring 2003) Richard
Talbot demonstrates an approach and method for constructing perspectival
space that may account for many of the distinguishing spatial
and compositional features of key Renaissance paintings. The
aim of the paper is also to show that this approach would not
necessarily require, as a prerequisite, any understanding of
the geometric basis and definitions of linear perspective as
established by Alberti. The author discusses paintings in which
the spatial/geometric structure has often defied conventional
reconstruction when the strict logic of linear perspective is
applied.
Visual
sensibility in Antiquity and the Renaissance: The Diminution
of the Classical Column David A. Vila Domini (Spring
2003) David Vila
Domini looks at the recommendations regarding optical adjustment
of the columnar diminution in the architectural treatises of
Vitruvius, Alberti, and Palladio. He examines the variation in
diminution of column thickness according to the height of the
column, and its implications for our understanding of the various
practices with regard both to columnar proportion and visual
sensibility in Antiquity and the Renaissance. He also examines
possible sources for the methods by which the ratios of column
height to diameter were derived.
How Should We Measure an Ancient
Structure? Harrison Eiteljorg, II (Autumn 2002) Harrison Eiteljorg,
II, examines the questions of precision and accuracy in the measurement
of ancient buildings, taking into account the separate requirements
of both scholarship and preservation. Modern technology has changed
matters significantly and promises to continue to bring change.
Whereas the problem was once measuring as precisely as possible
or as precisely as a scaled drawing could display, the problem
is now to measure and record as precisely as required for the
particular project. For each survey project, the answer must
be unique, but it must be well and carefully argued with respect
to the tools at hand and the subject. It is no longer appropriate
to assume that the most precise measurements are necessary. Technology
has advanced; now the decisions are ours.
The Double Möbius Strip Studies
Vesna Petresin and Laurent-Paul Robert (Autumn 2002) The curious single
continuous surface named after astronomer and mathematician August
Ferdinand Möbius has only one side and one edge. But it
was only in the past century that attention in mathematics was
drawn to studies of hyper- and fractal dimensions. As Vesna Petresin
and Laurent-Paul Robert show, the Möbius strip has a great
potential as an architectural form, but we can also use its dynamics
to reveal the mechanisms of our perception (or rather, its deceptions
as in the case of optical illusions) in an augmented space-time.
Villard de Honnecourt and Euclidian
Geometry Marie-Thérèse Zenner
(Autumn 2002) In
this reprint from a popular science journal, Marie-Thérèse
Zenner presents a brief overview of the survival of Latin Euclid
within the practical geometry tradition of builders, taking examples
from an eleventh-century French Romanesque church, Saint-Etienne
in Nevers, and a thirteenth-century Picard manuscript of drawings
(Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, MS fr. 19093), known as
the portfolio of Villard de Honnecourt.
Mathematics and Design: Yes, But
Will it Fly? Martin Davis and Matt Insall (Autumn
2002) Martin Davis
and Matt Insall discuss a quote by Richard W. Hamming about the
physical effect of Lebesgue and Riemann integrals and whether
it made a difference whether one or the other was used, for example,
in the design of an airplane. The gist of Hamming's quote was
that the fine points of mathematical analysis are not relevant
to engineering considerations.
A Light, Six-Sided, Paradoxical
Fight Marco Frascari (Spring 2002) Built structures and their architectural
representations are places where geometry, mathematics and construction
discover their common nature, that is, the capability of human
imagination to merge architectural objects with the telling of
enjoyable tales. In this ppaer Marco Frascari takes aim at the
forces that have shaped a system of critical thoughts on how
to fight gravity with a happy architecture based on light structures
combined with the dilettante's approaches to hexagonal design,
interweaving the thoughts of Alberti, Kahn and Le Ricolais with
those of master story-tellers Calvino and Rebelais.
The Fire Tower Elena
Marchetti and Luisa Rossi Costa (English
version) (Spring 2002) The
Fire Tower was a project by Johannes Itten, one of the most
important exponents of the Bauhaus movement. The aim of this
paper by Elena Marchetti and Luisa Rossi Costa is to describe
the shape of The Fire Tower with the language of linear
algebra and give a virtual reconstruction, in order to understand
how Itten managed to concretise his strong mathematical intuition
in an artistic form, even though he was unable to formalise it
entirely with adequate instruments.
La Torre di Fuoco Elena
Marchetti and Luisa Rossi Costa (versione
italiana) (Spring 2002) La Torre del Fuoco
è un progetto di Johannes Itten, uno dei più importanti
esponenti del Bauhaus. Scopo del presente lavoro di Elena Marchetti
e Luisa Rossi Costa è quello di descrivere la forma della
Torre del Fuoco attraverso il linguaggio dell'algebra
lineare e di darne una ricostruzione virtuale, nella consapevolezza
di quanto Itten fosse capace di concretizzare nell'arte il suo
forte intuito matematico, pur non potendo formalizzarlo fino
in fondo con adeguati strumenti.
The Golden Section in Architectural
Theory Marcus Frings (Winter 2002) In the never-ending
- but always young - discussion about the Golden Section in architecture
never lacks the hint at Luca Pacioli and the architectural theory.
But what always lacks is a thorough study of this topic, the
Golden Section in architectural theory. The paper aims to present
this analysis. Marcus Frings traces Golden Section from the mathematical
and rather theoretical character of Pacioli's concept, examines
Alberti, Serlio, Palladio and other architectural treatises,
to arrive to Adolf Zeising in the nineteenth century and to theorist
Matila Ghyka and the practitioners Ernst Neufert and Le Corbusier
in the twentieth. In the latter's writings and designs the Golden
Section seems to play the role of a scholarly element which shows
the master's theoretical erudition, leading to contemporary architects
such as Ricardo Bofill.
The Pythagopod Christopher
Glass (Winter 2002) In
1967 lecture at Yale Architecture School Anne Tyng discussed
integrating of the five Pythagorean solids into a single shape
and suggested the shape as an architectural solid. Christopher
Glass aim is to sphere the cube in the manner of Buckminster
Fuller, but with reference not only to the engineering models
he uses but to the cultural models of the Pythagorean proportions
as well. The author has developed computer models of the resulting
plan at least two scales: the original glass house and a smaller
hermitage pod.
More True Applications of the Golden
Number Dirk Huylebrouck and Patrick Labarque
(Winter 2002) Dirk
Huylebrouck and Patrick Labarque try to provide a positive answer
to the question that the golden section corresponds to an optimal
solution. It is but a college-level rephrasing exercise, but
it could reboot the mathematical career of the golden section.
An extension to the related silver section is given as well.
The authors betin their examination with the definition of the
golden number, then proceed to its applications to architecture,
grey-tone mixing, colour mixing and bicycle gears.
Spirals and the Golden
Section John Sharp (Winter 2002) The Golden Section is a fascinating topic
that continually generates new ideas. It also has a status that
leads many people to assume its presence when it has no relation
to a problem. It often forces a blindness to other alternatives
when intuition is followed rather than logic. Mathematical inexperience
may also be a cause of some of these problems. In the following,
my aim is to fill in some gaps, so that correct value judgements
may be made and to show how new ideas can be developed on the
rich subject area of spirals and the Golden section. The paper
is divided into four parts: Introduction; Types of spirals; Spirals
from the Golden rectangle, Triangles and the pentagon by approximation;
Mathematics of true Golden Section spirals; The myth of the nautilus
shell.
Palladio's Villa Emo: The Golden Proportion
Theory Rebutted Lionel March (Autumn 2001) In a most thoughtful
and persuasive paper [Fletcher 2000], Rachel Fletcher comes close
to convincing that Palladio may well have made use of the 'golden
section', or extreme and mean ratio, in the design of the Villa
Emo at Fanzolo. What is surprising is that a visually gratifying
result is so very wrong when tested by the numbers. Lionel March
provides an arithmetic analysis of the dimensions provided by
Palladio in the Quattro libri to reach new conclusions
about Palladio's design process.
Palladio's Villa Emo: The Golden
Proportion Theory Defended Rachel Fletcher (Autumn
2001) At Nexus 2000,
Rachel Fletcher argued that Palladio may well have made use of
the 'golden section', or extreme and mean ratio, in the design
of the Villa Emo at Fanzolo. In the Autumn, 2001 issue of Nexus
Network Journal, Lionel March argued that the Golden Section
is nowhere to be found in the Villa Emo as described in I
quattro libri dell'archittetura. In the present paper, Rachel
Fletcher defends her original thesis, comparing the Villa Emo
as actually built to the project for it that Palladio published
in his book.
Rosettes and Other Arrangements of
Circles Paul L. Rosin (Autumn 2001) The process of design in art and architecture
generally involves the combination and manipulation of a relatively
small number of geometric elements to create both the underlying
structures as well as the overlaid decorative details. In this
paper we concentrate on patterns created by copies of just a
single geometric form - the circle. The circle is an extremely
significant shape. By virtue of its simplicity and its topology
it has been highly esteemed by many different cultures for millennia,
symbolising God, unity, perfection, eternity, stability, etc.
For instance, Ralph Waldo Emerson considered the circle to be
"the highest emblem in the cipher of the world"
Violins and Volutes: Visual Parallels
between Music and Architecture Åke Ekwall
(Autumn 2001) In
early Greek architecture, above all in the Ionic order, the volute
was developed with particular perfection and grace. From 1957
to 1965, I carried out an extensive investigation into how the
violin acquired its singular shape. One aspect of violins that
I studied was the strong spiral line of the f-holes and scroll.
The present paper compares the constructions of Vitruvius, Alberti
and Palladio for the volute to my own analyses performed on the
scrolls of historic violins. It also seeks a parallel for constructions
of volutes with arcs of different degrees in the volutes of the
Medici Chapel by Michelangelo.
Group Theory and Architecture
II: Why Symmetry/Asymmetry? Michael Leyton
(Autumn 2001) This
is the second in a sequence of tutorials on the mathematical
structure of architecture. The first was Group Theory and Architecture 1 (NNJ vol. 3 no. 3 Summer 2001).
The purpose of these tutorials is to present, in an easy form,
the technical theory developed in Leyton's book, A
Generative Theory of Shape [Springer-Verlag,
2001], on the mathematical structure of design. In this second tutorial Michael Leyton
looks at the functional role of symmetry and asymmetry in
architecture.
Gothic Flemish Town Halls In
and Around Flanders, 1350-1550: A Geometric Analysis
Han Vandevyvere (Summer 2001) Han Vandevyvere undertakes an investigation
into some geometrical schemes that can be supposed to underlie
the plans and facades of a number of Flemish Gothic town halls.
Among the most famous of them, we can mention Brussels, Louvain,
Oudenaarde and Bruges, all of them built from the late 14th till
the early 16th century. To govern his study he founded a set
of basic ordering rules: a search for simple series of integer
numbers, so as to obtain simple
ratios between the dimensions; a check to see that what is found
to set up a plan is also found in the elevations; the preferential
use of geometrical constructions that can easily be constructed
with the compass and the carpenter's square; checking the design
in the measurement units that were in use at the moment and place
of construction; a check for the use of construction based on
a circle, its inscribed square and equilateral triangle.
The Engineering Achievements of Hardy
Cross Leonard K. Eaton (Summer 2001) Leonard K. Eaton resurrects
the reputation of Hardy Cross, developer of the "moment
distribution method" and one of America's most brilliant
engineers. The structural calculation of a large reinforced concrete
building in the nineteen fifties was a complicated affair. It
is a tribute to the engineering profession, and to Hardy Cross,
that them were so few failures. When architects and engineers
had to figure out what was happening in a statically indeterminate
frame, they inevitably turned to what was generally known as
the "moment distribution" or "Hardy Cross"
method. Although the Cross method has been superseded by more
powerful procedures such as the Finite Element Method, the "moment
distribution method" made possible the efficient and safe
design of many reinforced concrete buildings during an entire
generation.
Euclidism and Theory of Architecture
Michele Sbacchi (Summer 2001) Michele Sbacchi examines the impact of
the discipline of Euclidean geometry upon architecture and, more
specifically, upon theory of architecture. Special attention
is given to the work of Guarino Guarini, the 17th century Italian
architect and mathematician who, more than any other architect,
was involved in Euclidean geometry. Furthermore, the analysis
shows how, within the realm of architecture, a complementary
opposition can be traced between what is called "Pythagorean
numerology" and "Euclidean geometry." These two
disciplines epitomized two overlapping ways of conceiving architectural
design.
Group Theory and Architecture
I: Nested Symmetry Michael Leyton (Summer
2001) The present
series of articles by Michael Leyton, of which this is the first,
will give an introduction to a comprehensive theory of design
based on group theory in an intuitive form, and build up any
needed group theory through tutorial passages. The articles will
begin by assuming that the reader has no knowledge of group theory,
and we will progressively add more and more group theory in an
easy form, until we finally are able to get to quite difficult
topics in tensor algebras, and give a group-theoretic analysis
of complex buildings such as those of Peter Eisenman, Zaha Hadid,
Frank Gehry, Coop Himmelblau, Rem Koolhaas, Daniel Libeskind,
Greg Lynn, and Bernard Tschumi. This first article is on a subject
of considerable psychological relevance: nested symmetries.
Applications of a New Property
of Conics to Architecture: An Alternative Design Project for
Rio de Janeiro Metropolitan Cathedral Juan
V. Martín Zorraquino, Francisco Granero Rodríguez
and José Luis Cano Martín (Spring 2001) This paper describes
the mathematical discovery of a new property of conics which
allows the development of numerous geometric projects for use
in architectural and engineering applications. Illustrated is
an architectural application in the form of an alternative project
for Río de Janeiro Metropolitan Cathedral featuring of
the the integration of a ellipical base and a cross in the top
plane. Two alternative designs are presented for the cathedral,
based on the choice of either the Latin or Greek cross.
Modularity and the Number of Design
Choices Nikos Salingaros and Débora
M. Tejada (Spring 2001) Nikos
Salingaros and Débora Tejada analyze one aspect of what
is commonly understood as "modularity" in the architectural
literature. There are arguments to be made in favor of modularity,
but the authors argue against empty modularity, using mathematics
to prove their point. If we have a large quantity of structural
information, then modular design can organize this information
to prevent randomness and sensory overload. In that case, the
module is not an empty module, but a rich, complex module containing
a considerable amount of substructure. Empty modules, on the
other hand, eliminate internal information, and their repetition
eliminates information from the entire region that they cover.
Modularity works in a positive sense only when there is substructure
to organize.
On Precision in Architecture
Costantino Caciagli (English
version) (Spring 2001) In
architecture, the term precision, in the sense of "respect
for order and exactness", says everything and nothing. In
fact, "precision in architecture" can be used in reference
to diverse aspects such as the carrying out of program functions,
to execution, to forms, to distribution of forces, to dimensions,
but we could never arrive at a conclusion if the characteristics
taken into consideration were not commensurable to a reference
sample.
A proposito della precisione
in architettura Costantino Caciagli (versione
italiana)(Spring 2001) Precisione,
nel senso di "rispetto dell'ordine e dell'esattezza",
in architettura dice tutto e non dice nulla, infatti ci si può
riferire allo svolgimento delle funzioni alla esecuzione, alle
forme,alla distribuzione dei pesi, delle dimensioni, ma non potremmo
arrivare a nessuna conclusione, se i caratteri presi in considerazione
non sono commensurati ad un campione di riferimento.
Iannis Xenakis - Architect of
Light and Sound Alessandra Capanna (English
version) (Spring 2001) Alessandra
Capanna summarizes the life and work of Iannis Xenakis, who passed
away on 4 February 2001.He was a musician, but above all he was
a theorist and pure researcher who used mathematical thought
as a basis for of his compositions. Because of this, his way
of working more closely resembles that of a philosopher of science
than that of an artist, whose instinctive creations are sometimes
controlled only by aesthetical aims. he was also an architect.
In 1956 Le Corbusier entrusted his sketches for the Philips Pavilion
for the Brussels World's Fair to Xenakis, who was charged to
translate them through mathematics.
Iannis Xenakis -- Architetto
della luce e dei suoni Alessandra Capanna (versione
italiana) (Spring 2001) Alessandra
Capanna ripercorre il carierra di Iannis Xenakis, uno dei musicisti
contemporanei più celebri, scomparso il 4 febbraio 2001.
Un musicista, ma anche un teorico e un ricercatore puro che,
ponendo alla base di tutte le sue articolazioni compositive il
pensiero matematico. Era anche un'architetto. In ottobre del
1956 che egli ricevette da Le Corbusier l'incarico di tradurre
attraverso la matematicai suoi schizzi per la Padiglione
Philips per l'Expo di Bruxelles.
"Fractal Architecture":
Late Twentieth Century Connections Between Architecture and Fractal
Geometry Michael J. Ostwald (Winter 2001) For more than two decades
an intricate and contradictory relationship has existed between
architecture and the sciences of complexity. While the nature
of this relationship has shifted and changed throughout that
time a common point of connection has been fractal geometry.
Both architects and mathematicians have each offered definitions
of what might, or might not, constitute fractal architecture.
Curiously, there are few similarities between architects' and
mathematicians' definitions of "fractal architecture".
There are also very few signs of recognition that the other side's
opinion exists at all. Practising architects have largely ignored
the views of mathematicians concerning the built environment
and conversely mathematicians have failed to recognise the quite
lengthy history of architects appropriating and using fractal
geometry in their designs. Even scholars working on concepts
derived from both architecture and mathematics seem unaware of
the large number of contemporary designs produced in response
to fractal geometry or the extensive record of contemporary writings
on the topic. The present paper begins to address this lacuna.
Analysis and Synthesis in Architectural
Designs:A Study in Symmetry Jin-Ho Park
(Winter 2001) Ordered
designs are frequently encountered in art and architecture. The
underlying structure of their spatial logic may be discussed
with regard to the use of symmetry principles in mathematics.
In architectural designs, the use of symmetry may sometimes be
apparent immediately by just looking at designs, although the
final design is seemingly asymmetrical; or various symmetries
are manifested in the parts of the designs, yet not immediately
recognizable despite an almost obsessive concern for symmetry.
At this point, it is crucial to develop a formal methodology
that may clearly elucidate different hierarchical levels of the
use of symmetry in architectural designs.In an effort to do this,
before proceeding to analytic and synthetic applications, we
discuss a methodology founded on the algebraic structure of the
symmetry group of a regular polygon in mathematics. The approach
shows how various types of symmetry are superimposed in individual
designs, and illustrates how symmetry may be employed strategically
in the design process. Analytically, by viewing architectural
designs in this way, symmetry, which is superimposed in several
layers in a design, becomes transparent. Synthetically, architects
can benefit from being conscious of using group operations and
spatial transformations associated with symmetry in compositional
and thematic development. The advantage of operating with symmetry
concepts in this way is to provide architects with an explicit
method not only for the understanding of symmetrical structures
of sophisticated designs, but also to give architects insights
for the construction of new designs by using symmetry operations.
The Squaring of the Circle in two
Early Norwegian Cathedrals? Dag Nilsen (Winter
2001) The squaring
of the circle is impossible, but it can be represented geometrically,
as demonstrated by Dr.-Ing. Helmut Sander in "A
geometrical ensemble to generate the squaring of the circle".
I immediately recognized his diagram as being very close to a
diagram that I have found by analyzing two early Norwegian basilican- plan cathedrals, and which,
at first glance, I believed might have been used in determining
the ratios between some important dimensions. This spurred me
to make further investigations, revealing that it was not quite
that simple. However, this pursuit revealed some alternative,
but related possibilities, including a way of combining Ö2 and Ö5
-- albeit approximately, but close enough to fool a non-mathematician
working by small-scale geometry into make a false assumption
similar to Le Corbusier's when he was developing the Modulor.
UPDATED! Architecture,
Patterns and Mathematics Nikos Salingaros (April
1999, republished in an updated version Winter 2001) One of the roles served by architecture
is that of offering professionals and laymen alike the possibility
to experience mathematical pattern. Nikos Salingaros examines
how the revolution in architectural style at the end of the nineteenth
century and the beginning of the twentieth, aimed at banishing
an irrevelant architectural ornamentation, also banished pattern
from architecture, much to the detriment of man's experience
of the built environment. Using the architecture of Mies van
der Rohe and Le Corbusier and the theories of Christopher Alexander
as a base, the author explains the malady and the cure for twentieth
century architecture. This paper appears
in print in the Nexus
Network Journal 1 (1999): 75-85.
The Arithmetic of Nicomachus
of Gerasa and its Applications to Systems of Proportion
Jay Kappraff (October 2000) Nicomachus
of Gerasa has gained a position of importance in the history
of ancient mathematics due in great measure to his Introduction
to Arithmetic, one of the only surviving documentations of
Greek number theory. Prof. Kappraff discusses a pair of tables
of integers found in the Arithmetic and shows how they
lead to a general theory of proportion, including the system
of musical proportions developed by the neo-Platonic Renaissance
architects Leon Battista Alberti and Andrea Palladio, the Roman
system of proportions described by Theon of Smyrna, and the Modulor
of Le Corbusier. This paper appears
in print in Nexus Network
Journal 2 (2000): 41-55.
Introduction to Slavik Jablan's Modular
Games Donald W. Crowe (October
2000) Donald Crowe,
Professor emeritus of mathematics at the University of Wisconsin
and known for his collaboration with Dorothy Washburn on the
book Symmetries of Culture : Theory and Practice of Plane
Pattern Analysis, introduces a new interactive tiling program
by Slavik Jablan called Modular Games, also published
in the issue of the NNJ. Prof. Crowe provides an overview
of the program's function as well as a brief background to the
concepts of tiling and combinatorials. This
paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 2 (2000): 15-16.
Modular
Games Slavik Jablan (October 2000) Slavik Jablan, editor of the e-journal
VisMath,
has created an interactive tiling program for the NNJ.
Jablan presents four sets of prototiles called OpTiles,
SpaceTiles, Orn(amental)Tiles and KnotTiles.
Each involves a small set of square tiles which can be combined
by the reader in various orientations and reversals to make a
bewildering array of designs and patterns. The reader may contemplate
his or her constructions at leisure, and with a simple inkjet
printer they can be printed out to use in any way you like. This program appears as a Supplementary CD to
the Nexus Network
Journal 2 (2000).
Hugues Libergier and His Instruments
Nancy Wu (October 2000). One
of the most frequently illustrated images of a medieval architect
is the tomb slab of Hugues Libergier, architect of the Abbey
of Saint-Nicaise in Reims. Hugues (d. 1263) is immortalized by
a famous effigy now found in the Cathedral of Reims. As might
be expected from the effigy of an architect, it is accompanied
by several instruments of his profession: a square, a compass,
and a measuring rod. These instruments are frequently found in
conjunction with the representation of architects, on tomb slabs,
sculpture, in construction scenes on manuscript pages or stained
glass panels, the subject of study by scholars in search of the
secrets of medieval construction. This
paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 2 (2000): 93-102.
Methodology in Architecture
and Mathematics: Nexus 2000 Round Table Discussion
Carol Martin Watts, Moderator (October 2000). The
Nexus 2000 round table discussion on methodology in architecture
and mathematics took place on Tuesday 6 June during the course
of the Nexus 2000 conference in Ferrara, Italy. Moderated by
Carol Martin Watts, the panelists were Rachel Fletcher, Paul
Calter, William D. (Bill) Sapp and Mark Reynolds. This report
is a transcript of the audio tapes made during the discussion,
which covered three areas:
PART I: HOW IMPORTANT IS ACCURACY?
PART II: WHAT IS THE NATURE OF MATHEMATICS? PART III: HOW DO WE DIFFER IN OUR APPROACHES TO THE
WHOLE RELATIONSHIPS OF MATHEMATICS AND ARCHITECTURE BASED ON
OUR DISCIPLINES?
The workshop discussion appears in
print in Nexus Network
Journal 2 (2000): 105-130.
The Relationship Between Architecture
and Mathematics in the Pantheon Giangiacomo Martines
(July 2000). An
examination of the latest Pantheon studies illustrates the newest
theories of relationships between architecture and mathematics
in Rome's most celebrated building. This paper was presented
at the Nexus 2000 conference on architecture and mathematics,
4-7 June 2000, Ferrara, Italy. Many studies on the Pantheon are
carried out far from Rome and so ideas on the monument cannot
be checked easily or frequently. For this reason, a group of
architects and archaeologists are working in Rome , trying to
resolve some seemingly banal but still unanswered questions.
For instance, one question that is often asked is: Could the
inside of the Pantheon have been an astronomical observatory?
This paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 2 (2000):
57-61.
How to Construct a Logarithmic Rosette
(Without Even Knowing It) Paul Calter (April
2000) Paul Calter
explains what a logarithmic rosette is and gives some examples
of their occurrence in pavements. Then he gives a simple construction
method which is totally geometric and requires no calculation.
He then proves that it gives a logarithmic rosette, with the
exception that the spirals are made up of straight-line segments
rather than curved ones. This paper
appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 2 (2000): 25-31.
Under Siege: The Golden Mean in
Architecture Michael Ostwald (April 2000) Michael Ostwald
briefly describes the Golden Mean and its history before examining
the stance taken by a number of recent authors investigating
the Golden Mean in architecture. He addresses the theories of
Husserl, Derrida and Ingraham, who separately affirm that tacit
assumptions about the relationship between geometric forms and
other forms - say geometry and architecture - must be constantly
questioned if they are to retain any validity. This
paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 2 (2000): 75-81.
Pythagorean Triangles and the Musical
Proportions Martin Euser (April
2000) Martin Euser researches the factor root-(2N -
1) and its interesting relations between musical proportions
and Pythagorean triangles. The simple scheme N +/- root-N is
also interesting as a generative set of pairs of numbers. This
set looks like a prototype for the generative set of pairs of
numbers discussed in a previous article by the author. The findings
are presented summarily and it is left to the reader to elaborate
upon them. This paper appears
in print in Nexus Network
Journal 2 (2000): 33-40.
Pavements as Embodiments of
Meaning for a Fractal Mind Terry M. Mikiten, Nikos
A. Salingaros, Hing-Sing Yu (April 2000) This paper puts forward a fractal theory
of the human mind that explains one aspect of how we interact
with our environment. Some interesting analogies are developed
for storing ideas and information within a fractal scheme. The
mind establishes a connection with the environment by processing
information, this being an important theme seen during the evolution
of the brain. The authors assert that pavements play a role in
connecting human beings to surrounding structures by acting as
a vehicle for conveying meaning, and argue that the design on
pavements transfers meaning from our surroundings to our awareness.
This paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 2 (2000):
63-74.
Pisa baptistry is giant musical
instrument, computers show Rory Carroll (April
2000) A music professor
at the University of Pisa and a Catholic priest have joined forces
to show that the extraordinary acoustics of the Baptistery in
Pisa are intentional and that it is a large musical instrument.
The Architecture of Curved Shapes
Kazimierz Butelski (January 2000) In the 20th century, architecture remains
the part of art where formal principles are very important for
creators and spectators. Because form in architecture is so important,
two questions arise: How can architects nowadays create forms?
How can forms be described and classified? When we work only
with formal analysis, we can point to an important criterion
of innovation, that is, that certain forms have never before
been seen in the history of architecture. In
the present day, CAD/CAM technology permits us to realize any
form our imaginations can create. This
paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 2 (2000): 19-25.
Environmental Patterns: Paving Designs
by Tess Jaray Kim Williams (January 2000) There is no greater
opportunity for mathematics and architecture to interact than
in paving designs. Where walls are often broken by windows, doors
and pilasters, or are covered by paintings, and ceilings (especially
modern ceilings) are occupied by lighting fixtures, air vents
and smoke alarms (once called "ceiling acne" by architect
Robert Stern), floors are usually large unbroken surfaces. For
this reason, pavement design has flourished from ancient times.
Kim Williams discusses the pavements for urban centers and
public spaces designed by British Artist Tess Jaray. Jaray's
patterns are derived from the proportional properties of the
bricks she uses, and are inspired by the centuries' old masonry
tradition. Jaray's designs are a geometric link between architecture
and mathematics. This paper appears
in print in Nexus Network
Journal 2 (2000): 87-92.
A Geometrical Ensemble to Generate
the Squaring of the Circle Helmut Sander (English version) (January
2000) The purely
geometrical squaring of the circle with straightedge and compass
is possible only within the tolerance of an approximation. But
knowing the value of the irrational number pi of the circle
(p = 3,14159265
...), it is possible to transform it as a line or rather
as a shape of a circle or a square. This
paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 2 (2000): 83-85.
Ein Schaubild zur Kreisquadratur
Helmut Sander (Deutsche
Version) (January 2000) Die
rein geometrische Kreisquadratur init Zirkel und Lineal hat sich
längst als nur annähernd möglich erwiesen. Weil
aber die Kreiszahl Pi mit p
= 3,14159265... bekannt ist, lässt sie sich trotzdem als
Strecke und sogar als Kreis- oder Quadratfläche darstellen.
In the Footsteps of the Prince: A Look at Renaissance Ferrara
Charles M. Rosenberg. (October 1999) The narrow cobblestone streets of Ferrara,
some scarcely wider than a footpath, give a real sense of what
the city was like in the middle ages and early Renaissance: the
Via Chiodaiuoli, street of the ironmongers, crossed by a file
of slim, brick buttresses; the Via Ragno, lined by typical red-brick
houses with protruding sporti; the dramatic Via Volte,
bridged by a succession of enormous pointed vaults supporting
the second and third stories of buildings which actually span
the roadway; the still vibrant arcaded commercial Via Romano,
as well as the more twisting paths in the district of the castrum.
The history of Ferrara and its princes has left a clear and readable
imprint on the city's streets, palaces and churches. Written
in their stones is the memory of what has gone before. (Ferrara was the site of the Nexus
2000 conference on architecture and
mathematics). No longer online, this paper appears in print
in the Nexus Network
Journal 1 (1999): 43-63.
A Comparative Geometric Analysis
of the Heights and Bases of the Great Pyramid of Khufu and the
Pyramid of the Sun at Teotihuacan Mark Reynolds.
(October 1999) Looking
back into the murky mysteries of ancient times, there are reminders
of past glories in the art, architecture, and design of our ancestors,
and, in the number systems they employed in those designs. These
number systems were clearly expressed in the geometry they used.
Among these works are the mammoth pyramids that dot the Earth's
surface. Accurate in their placement as geodetic markers and
mechanically sophisticated as astronomical observatories, these
wonders of ancient science stand as reminders that our brethren
of antiquity may well have known more than we think. This paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 1 (1999):
23-42.
Study the Works of Peter Eisenman?
Why?! Adriana Rossi (English
version). (October 1999) In
architecture it is possible to demonstrate, as Peter Eisenman
states, "...all the changes can in some way refer to cultural
changes... the most tangible changes... were determinated by
technological progress, by the development of new conditions
of use and by the change in meaning of certain rituals and their
field of representation" [Eisenman, 1989]. Thus in the simple
use of geometric solids, he limits himself to the promotion of
a language orientated with a correspondent systematic order.
In the spatial manipulations of plans and sections, Eisenman
experiments with the "laws of thought" (1854) put in
place in the nineteenth century by George Boole and Augustus
De Morgan. In the same way that the two English logicians brought
to extreme consequences the Aristotelian syllogisms which prelude
to mechanised reasoning, Peter Eisenman manipulates an idea,
submitting it to a sort of propositional calculation. Through
probings and attempts which follow each other in a sequence of
approximations made possible by a new conception of notation
and representation, and beginning with elementary solids or simple
internal relations, architectural space takes shape. This paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 1 (1999):
65-74.
Studiare le opere di Peter Eisenman?
Perché?! Adriana Rossi (versione
italiana). (October 1999). In
architettura, si può dimostrare -come afferma Peter Eisenman-
che: "...tutti i cambiamenti possono in qualche modo far
riferimento a cambiamenti culturali... i mutamenti più
tangibili... sono stati determinati dal progresso tecnologico,
dallo sviluppo di nuove condizioni d'uso e dal cambiamento del
significato di certi rituali e del loro campo di rappresentazione"
[Eisenman, 1989]. Cosicchè nel fare semplice uso di solidi
geometrici, si limita a promuovere un linguaggio orientato insieme
a un corrispondente ordine sistematico. Nelle manipolazioni spaziali
di piante e sezioni Eisenman sperimenta le "Leggi del pensiero"
(1854), messe a punto nell'ottocento da George Boole e Augustus
De Morgan. Come i due logici inglesi portavano alle estreme conseguenze
i sillogismi aristoteliani che preludono ai ragionamenti meccanizzati,
così Peter Eisenman manipola l'idea, sottoponendola ad
una sorta di calcolo proposizionale.
Architectural Traces of an Admirable Cipher: Eleven in
the Opus of Carlo Scarpa Marco
Frascari. (July 1999) Consciously
or unconsciously, part of the apparatus that architects use in
their daily fabrications of the built environment grows out of
their understanding of numbers and numerals. Embodied in tectonic
events and parts, numbers hinge the past and the future of buildings
and their inhabitants into a search for a way of life with no
impairment caused by psychic activity. Whether sensible or intelligible,
tectonic numbers articulate the vigor of human mind's eye, and
ultimately they refer to psychic regimes immersed in the vital
ocean of imagination and wonder. The essential influence on Scarpa's
numerical thinking is the combinatorial procedures devised by
Raymond Roussel for writing his books, the upturned geometry
of Rene A. Schwaller De Lubicz and Surrealistic processes of
invention. Scarpa's architecture is a prudent and playful project
that relates to the traces of numbers embodied in a tradition.
In Scarpa's opus, it is true that One and One Equals Two,
but it is also wonderfully true that A Pair of Ones Makes
an Eleven. No longer available online,
this paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 1 (1999): 7-21.
Architecture and Mathematics in the Gothic of the Mendicants
Marcello Spigaroli (English
version) (July 1999) The universal essence of beauty consists
of the resplendence of form on the material parts in proportion. This luminous statement
by Albertus Magnus could be chosen as the synthesis of the esthetic
thought of the thirteenth century, and more generally, of the
entire late medieval period. The whole range of philosophy and
science of this period centers on the theme of proportional relationships
as the origin of unity, coherence and the intelligibility of
the universe and its infinite parts. From the mendicant orders
would come the major exponents of the scientific philosophy,
the assumptions of which hinged on the principle of proportions.
The city is the theatre where beauty and truth coincide in celebration
of political power founded on a mercantile economy, justifying
at once an ideology and a way of life. No
longer available online, this paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 1 (1999):
105-115.
The Sky Within: Mathematical Aesthetics of Persian Dome
Interiors Reza Sarhangi. (July 1999) In the absence of metal beams, domes had
been an essential part of the architecture of official and religious
buildings around the world for several centuries. Domes were
used to bring the brick structure of the building to conclusion.
Based on their spherical constructions, they provided strength
to the building foundations and also made the structure more
resistant against snow and wind. Besides bringing a sense of
strength and protection, the interior designs and decorations
resemble sky, heaven, and what a person may expect to see beyond
"seven skies." Some contemporary religious buildings
or memorials still incorporate domes, no longer out of necessity,
but rather based on tradition or for esthetical purposes. Yet
the quality of the interior decoration of these new domes is
diminishing. The aim of this article is to study the spatial
effects created by dome interior designs and to provide information
about construction of such a design. Decorations in dome interiors
demonstrate art forms such as stucco, tessellated work, ceramics,
paintings, mirror work, and brick pattern construction, as well
as combinations of these forms. No longer
available online, This paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 1 (1999):
87-97.
Cosmati Pavements at Westminster Abbey John
Sharp (April 1999). Architecture
in thirteenth century England was as much of a textbook as it
was a shelter. John Sharp examines one of the most beautiful
"texts": the decorated pavements created by Cosmati
artists for Henry III. Besides explaining technical details of
the panels such as materials and workmanship, Sharp reveals the
number symbolism of the inscription that surrounds the Great
Pavement, showing how sacred meaning was encrypted in a mathematical
symbol system. No longer available online,
this paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 1 (1999): 99-104.
Spirals and Rosettes in Architectural Ornament Kim
Williams (April 1999). By
now noted for both its frequency and its many variations in nature,
the spiral has inspired architectural forms for many centuries.
The logarithmic spiral was adapted by the Greeks for the ionic
volute; many generations of architects developed geometrical
constructions to approximate the curves of the spiral. A development
on the theme of the spiral is the fan pattern, in which spiral
segments are translated about the center of a circle. The superimposition
of opposing fan patterns results in the rosette. The easily-constructed
circular rosette is an ancient and beautiful pavement pattern,
and can be varied to lay the base for many other motives. No longer available online, This paper appears
in print in Nexus Network
Journal 1 (1999): 129-138.
Re-issued! The
Mathematics of Palladio's Villas: Workshop '98 Stephen
R. Wassell (April 1999) Stephen
Wassell describes the aims and results of the 1998 and 1999 workshop
tours of the villas of Renaissance architect Andrea Palladio.
An interdisciplinary group of scholars took advantage of visits
to nine villas in Italy's Veneto region to examine Palladio's
use of proportions, geometry and symmetry. A review of the literature
purtaining to Palladio's use of these mathematical principles
sets the stage for new work to be produced by workshop participants.
This paper appears in print in Nexus Network Journal 1 (1999):
121-128.
Re-issued! "Triangulature"
in Andrea Palladio Vera W. de Spinadel (January
1999). At the June
1998 workshop on the architecture of Andrea Palladio, the dimensions
of the rooms were much remarked. Vera Spinadel convincingly argues
that Palladio used precise mathematical relationships as a basis
for selecting the numerical dimensions for the rooms in this
villas. The integer dimensions are demonstrated to be approximants
linked to continued equations, and a particular way of deriving
these integers through the use of a continued fraction expansion
that approximates by excess is introduced. This
paper appears in print in Nexus
Network Journal 1 (1999): 117-119.
Didn't find what you were looking for? Search the
NNJ
|
top of
page |
NNJ Homepage
Search the
NNJ
Order
Nexus Books!
Didactics
Geometer's
Angle
Book
Reviews
Conference and Exhibit Reports
Readers'
Queries
The Virtual Library
Submission Guidelines
Top
of Page
|